Skip to main content
Islam

Return to Question

replaced http://islam.stackexchange.com/ with https://islam.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
Community Bot
Community Bot
  • 1

I am asking about this kind of question : http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/36202/must-we-believe-in-a-hidden-variable-for-quantum-indeterminacy/https://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/36202/must-we-believe-in-a-hidden-variable-for-quantum-indeterminacy/ . It has been put on hold as "unclear what you are asking", while with this formulation, the question asks for a yes/no answer. I tried to answer it, along with another user, and in the comments, both answers have been pointed out as "not answering the question". Both answers do (both argue in the favor of "no").

I get why this would seem unclear to someone not really interested in quantum mechanics, and I know most people are not.

Are all questions meant to a small audience off-topic because they are unclear to most users ?

It would seem rather odd to me to rule out questions on the basis of their small audience, since some others about specific topics can be found (finance, savings, translations, specific schools of islam, ...)

I am asking about this kind of question : http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/36202/must-we-believe-in-a-hidden-variable-for-quantum-indeterminacy/ . It has been put on hold as "unclear what you are asking", while with this formulation, the question asks for a yes/no answer. I tried to answer it, along with another user, and in the comments, both answers have been pointed out as "not answering the question". Both answers do (both argue in the favor of "no").

I get why this would seem unclear to someone not really interested in quantum mechanics, and I know most people are not.

Are all questions meant to a small audience off-topic because they are unclear to most users ?

It would seem rather odd to me to rule out questions on the basis of their small audience, since some others about specific topics can be found (finance, savings, translations, specific schools of islam, ...)

I am asking about this kind of question : https://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/36202/must-we-believe-in-a-hidden-variable-for-quantum-indeterminacy/ . It has been put on hold as "unclear what you are asking", while with this formulation, the question asks for a yes/no answer. I tried to answer it, along with another user, and in the comments, both answers have been pointed out as "not answering the question". Both answers do (both argue in the favor of "no").

I get why this would seem unclear to someone not really interested in quantum mechanics, and I know most people are not.

Are all questions meant to a small audience off-topic because they are unclear to most users ?

It would seem rather odd to me to rule out questions on the basis of their small audience, since some others about specific topics can be found (finance, savings, translations, specific schools of islam, ...)

Source Link
user5751924
user5751924
  • 381
  • 1
  • 5

Are questions about a narrow field off topic?

I am asking about this kind of question : http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/36202/must-we-believe-in-a-hidden-variable-for-quantum-indeterminacy/ . It has been put on hold as "unclear what you are asking", while with this formulation, the question asks for a yes/no answer. I tried to answer it, along with another user, and in the comments, both answers have been pointed out as "not answering the question". Both answers do (both argue in the favor of "no").

I get why this would seem unclear to someone not really interested in quantum mechanics, and I know most people are not.

Are all questions meant to a small audience off-topic because they are unclear to most users ?

It would seem rather odd to me to rule out questions on the basis of their small audience, since some others about specific topics can be found (finance, savings, translations, specific schools of islam, ...)