Questions tagged [quality-control]
The quality-control tag has no usage guidance.
14
questions
5
votes
3answers
82 views
Examining fatwa-request questions
There's currently some momentum on chat behind changing the off-topic close reasons. So I'm writing this post to identify some example fatwa-request questions, as mentioned in chat. This is a ...
2
votes
1answer
109 views
Why is answer #25472 upvoted? How is it in any way useful to the question?
A recent post ("Is this hadith aunthentic? "...so seek treatment (of illness) but do not treat (illness) with anything that is haraam."") is asking a fairly concise question: Is such-and-...
9
votes
4answers
395 views
The importance of writing complete answers: How to stop opinion-bait from ruining your site
First of all, I would like to point everyone to the seminal blog post "Real Questions Have Answers"; I know I've linked to it a few times in the past, but I think plenty of people here really could ...
12
votes
3answers
365 views
How can we discourage users from using the site to preach Truth
Even (almost) three years since the site opened, answers on the main page are still far more heavily "Truthy" than neutral/academic: Many posts are written with a bias that "Islam" has exactly one "...
4
votes
2answers
105 views
What should be done about fatwa questions where the questioner doesn't specify any particular school, but the accepted answer is specific to one?
A number of fatwa questions, especially older ones, ask for rulings about particular matters, but do not specify which (if any) school they're actually seeking answers from. These questions are often ...
1
vote
3answers
109 views
How do this site filters out answers from scholar vs non scholar?
Islam to Muslims is an essential part of their life. It is not an academic or technical thing to play around, so I was wondering how does this site filter out answers from scholars vs non scholars?
...
4
votes
1answer
110 views
I read a thing does this mean…?
I've noticed a trend in questions, in which basically a question is asked of the form "I just read a [fatwa|ayah|hadith], does this mean [extrapolated ruling applicable to all Muslims everywhere]?" A ...
14
votes
2answers
355 views
Do evidences speak for themselves?
We here have had a long and ugly history of copy-paste; as a site we actually seem to have had some success at discouraging these posts, which is an important step toward distinguishing us as a ...
8
votes
3answers
607 views
Is there any way to make Truth questions constructive?
I have recently gone through the review queue, and came across a lot of low-quality and/or first/late answers which were answers to very weak questions. Many of these questions were basically of the ...
8
votes
1answer
297 views
What is a fallacy, and why is it so bad?
I recently had a post criticised for being fallacious. It also may have been downvoted and/or deleted, which sucks especially because I know my conclusion was correct.
What is a fallacy, and why is ...
8
votes
3answers
286 views
We need to set a standard for fatwa questions
The issue of allowing fatwa questions on this site has been brought up before. The two most pertinent examples I recall are,
Islam: Should requests for rulings and/or fatawa be permitted?
A higher ...
-2
votes
2answers
138 views
Can we improve moderation?
I have argued in the past either in chat or on meta that we have a couple of issues with moderation here. I am writing here once again in hope of improving it.
Problem 1 - Ego Issue
I asked this ...
-2
votes
1answer
98 views
How can we create a friendly environment on Islam.SE and deal with sectarianism?
In my past couple of chats, my comments are constantly been deleted by one of the moderator. If I express my opinion which that is slightly against moderation (not a moderator) my comments are deleted ...
8
votes
2answers
160 views
What guidelines should we impose on questions to ensure quality?
I have noticed a trend in the posts on this site, where a question is asked under the (apparently) implicit assumption that all Muslims follow a single unified doctrine called "Islam."
In a lot of ...
