3

Should it be allowed to ask for religious text e.g. Text of the condolence which is given to Muhammad(saww) on the Day of Ashura?, which is available in religious books but not available over the internet, along with the translation and possibly the transliteration as well?

6
  • Why not allow this? – Ansari Jan 13 '14 at 21:47
  • Just a discussion. Plus I didn't want this to be characterized as Religious/spiritual healing and prescriptions. – Bleeding Fingers Jan 13 '14 at 21:57
  • Plus the community should have say and it's better to bring it up rather than assume. – Bleeding Fingers Jan 13 '14 at 21:58
  • are you sure reputable duas are not available on internet? duas.org if you mean books like deviated sufism, then that is a different matter. but authentic duas have no problem. – Battle of Karbala Jan 14 '14 at 7:21
  • 1
    Sometimes it's better to bring it up and assume, i.e. post your question on the main site normally, then bring up the discussion on meta pointing to and/or defending your post. Seeing a concrete example, and how the community reacts to it, can be valuable for discussion. – goldPseudo Jan 15 '14 at 0:54
  • @goldPseudo Point noted and concurred. – Bleeding Fingers Jan 15 '14 at 5:56
3

In general, I don't see a problem with this. It mostly sounds like a case of , which is to say you are searching for a particular and specific reference, rather than a vague "Are there any dua for..." (which would effectively just be a list question).

In other words, it's objectively answerable. You're not seeking items, or ideas, or opinions, you're seeking an answer, and you know (or reasonably suspect) that there is an existing text out there which does answer your question.

As long as the question itself is good (i.e. not just an excuse to copy-paste text verbatim from a third-party), the requested source being online or offline shouldn't make a difference (although, under the principle of Making the Internet a Better Place, I'd love to see more offline-specific requests since that information is otherwise so difficult to find online).

Whether the question and requested source is any good (which is to say useful) would have to be left up to community voting; even if we wanted to, I doubt we could really set any hard and fast rules on what is, and is not, useful to the community. Like any question, the onus is still on the questioner to prove its value.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .