3

a recent question on islam.se was an exact duplicate question, but its duplicated from a different website.

my question is, if it is considered plagiarism to copy a question from a different website, or if its required to add a list of sources if you do so.

Another thing to point out is that the answer on the question is also from the same website, although it does add sources. If the person answering has to add sources, why doesn't the questionnaire?

| |
6

(note: I'm just here as a regular user; please ignore the ♦ - I'm trying very hard not to act in a moderation capacity here; my answer here is not binding, etc)

Copying something from elsewhere (esp. passing it off as your own) is plagiarism; that is pretty much the definition. In this case, the question is such a 1-liner that it could quite conceivably be 2 people genuinely asking the same question - there are, after all, only so many ways of asking the same question. Personally, I think this also demonstrates that perhaps islam.SE should encourage a bit more "meat" to questions, rather than just a 1-liner. What have they considered? What have they looked at? What views have they considered? What conclusions have they drawn already? etc. If a question fits on one line, it probably needs more work!

When it comes to something larger (for example, the answer that was copied verbatim from another site), it isn't enough just to indicate where it came from. That can lead to all sorts of problems with copyright etc. A better approach is usually to actually write your own answer, perhaps referencing external sources (maybe with a minimal citation from the external site). That makes it clear that the answer is your own, and didn't just come from Google.

If the person answering has to add sources, why doesn't the questionnaire?

Well, copying a question from another site also probably isn't a good thing. In this case, the question is so minimal that it is hard to say definitively whether it was copied, versus two people independently having the same question.

| |
  • hehe.... i only noticed the star when you pointed it out ^_^ – NesreenA Aug 13 '12 at 18:20
  • +1 for meaty questions. IMO we're really lacking in hardcore, SO-style difficult questions in that vein. I think we haven't tapped our potential there. – ashes999 Aug 14 '12 at 10:53
3

I believe the questions should be asked for a reason and not just something you find from a Google search. With that said, just to be on the safe side, I have edited my answer on the question to only copy across the hadith (I could type out the same thing from Sahih Bukhari but I'm a tad lazy!) For forums like this to work, things need to run in a certain way :)

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .