This is an issue we will never be free of - any site on Islam will receive a constant stream of questions that seek a "fatwa" - the legal status of something, whether it is permissible or not permissible. While this is not a fatwa website, I don't think we can be unwelcoming of these questions. Additionally, this would be a good thing because most fatwa websites only offer or discuss one opinion. Here we could become a repository of the different existing opinions on an issue.
At the same time, most users of this website are not independent legal jurists and are therefore unqualified to offer their own opinion on such questions. Given the high search visibility of this website we don't want this website to become a source of sin for anyone and we don't want to be a source of propagation of legal opinions that are not from people who are trained.
And finally, if we become a website with a significant portion of our questions being fatwa questions and a significant number of amateur fatawa responses, we will drive away serious Muslims from participating on this website. And if that happens, this site goes into oblivion.
How do we want to deal with this? (see my proposal below)