The question Is converting to Islam easier than Judaism? has now received four close votes, and I'm wondering why:
Question: Why is "Is converting to Islam easier than Judaism?" being voted as off topic?
It doesn't seem to be a clear-cut case to me, so it seems like something we should establish on meta.
It's a comparative religion question. I made an argument here as to why I think such questions should be on topic: Are comparative studies on-topic? If we're going to vote to close comparative religion questions, we should have a tangible reason for doing so, i.e.,
"This is off-topic because X, Y, and Z, as discussed here: [link to meta thread]."
"This is off-topic because I feel it's off topic."
I get the feeling that maybe the votes are due to it being half off-topic, by being half about Judaism.