Why was this question closed? It was a clear question asking whether there might be a reconciliation between the Hadith and a historical fact.

1 Answer 1


For the same reason it was closed the first second time you posted it:

We are not a site for polemic and debate. Please focus this question to make it clear what exactly your practical answerable question is and what you're expecting in an answer.

Your first attempt at posting that question was originally closed as a duplicate of an already answered question which covered exactly what you had asked,, after which you merely changed the wording to the current form with no attempt or explanation as to why the extant answer is insufficient.

And the current form uses exactly the same kind of polemic/apologetic wordplay that, as I've already explained, is not welcome on this site.

That post was closed and subsequently deleted, as was your second attempt to post the same thing. Your third fourth attempt at posting the question again put in absolutely zero effort to actually focus the question, to make it clear, or to demonstrate that it's not polemic, beyond adding a comment stating that "This is a clear question…" (such comments, in my experience, never actually make anything clearer). So it was, again, closed and deleted.

  • You have accused me of posting polemic question so you are the ones who have to demonstrate that it is polemic!!
    – Amin
    Jul 24, 2014 at 5:43
  • 2
    @Amin No, the onus is on you to write a clear and acceptable question. I have told you this before.
    – goldPseudo Mod
    Jul 24, 2014 at 5:44

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .