1

There are many issues in Islam where there is no clear consensus (covering women's faces for instance). Can someone ask and say something like "This is issue X. What are the arguments for it, and what are the arguments against?"

2

I think these questions ought to be allowed. They are precisely the types of questions experts ought to be asking.

However, I think it is usually (there are always exceptions) best to ask it as two questions; one question asking for the position in support of a position, and another asking for the position in opposition. This is usually best for the simple reason that it makes it possible to accept the best answer.

If you ask for both pro- and con- arguments for a single issue, you may end up with two correct answers, but can only accept one.

If you want both sides of an issue, I suggest asking two questions.

4

I think it would very much depend on how the question was worded. For example, the question in OP (i.e., What are the arguments for it, and what are the arguments against?) is just too close to a "list question" to really fit on the site. You're likely to end up with a bunch of partial answers explaining one particular argument (either for or against) but unlikely to ever get anything that resembles a canonical answer.

On the other hand, if the question were worded more like "Could someone explain the controversy surrounding issue X?", they are more likely to get a proper answer. Rather than just a list of arguments, which the first question is (technically) asking for, you're getting a breakdown on the controversy itself, why there is even a disagreement in the first place. Such an answer would (ideally) include sample evidences and arguments for both sides of the issue.

Obligatory blog link: http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/09/good-subjective-bad-subjective/

0

These questions should not be allowed.

They are almost guaranteed to cause debate, which is Not Constructive, and will be closed anyways.

5
  • Yes, definitely. This is exactly why the "Not Constructive" closure exists. From the description: "This question is not a good fit for our Q&A format. We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or specific expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion. If you feel that this question can be improved and possibly reopened, see the FAQ for guidance." Jun 22 '12 at 20:46
  • If they are going to be closed anyways because of being non-constructive there is no need to make a new rule to deal with them separately. There are various expert opinions on almost all issue in Islam and forbidding them just because there is not a consensus doesn't make sense at all. If the questions are phrase in non-controversial terms there should be a problem and it should not lead to a debate or extensive arguments, each answer should give information not debate which one is the true one. We will have hard time to find any issue that there is clear consensus over it by Muslim scholars.
    – Kaveh
    Jun 23 '12 at 4:39
  • @Kaveh I disagree. Stack Exchange is not meant for discussion and Not Constructive questions. If there is not one correct answer, then it is not fit for the format here. If Muslim scholars do not agree on an answer, and there are more than 2-3 viewpoints, then it should be closed.
    – Dynamic
    Jun 23 '12 at 17:12
  • @Dynamic, "Stack Exchange is not meant for discussion and Not Constructive questions." that's consistent with what I said. "If there is not one correct answer, then it is not fit for the format here." that is not correct, check the blog.SO. This is a misconception that several people seem to have. Even completely subjective questions are fine as long as they follow the guidelines for great subjective questions.
    – Kaveh
    Jun 24 '12 at 4:29
  • You can find the blog.SO post about subjective questions here. If you have a reference for your claim that questions where there are more than one viewpoint among experts are not welcome on SE network please provide a link to it. As a moderator on another SE site for almost two years I haven't seen anything like that.
    – Kaveh
    Jun 24 '12 at 4:32
0

I think it is fine to ask about reasons and justifications for religious issues including clothing. There are lots of issues (almost every issue?) that there is not a consensus among Muslim scholars over them. Why should we not allow such questions?

On the other hand, debating or arguing over them on the site is not fine since this is not a forum, it is a Q&A site. Questions should be phrased politely and should be real question (not means to express one's opinion or criticize other people's opinions). Such questions can be closed as not-a-real-question (the OP doesn't really have a question although the post might use a question format) and/or not-constructive.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .