I have seen a number of questions show up on the site, usually in the form of "Is such-and-such common practice valid according to Islamic law?" or "Is so-and-so group wrong for practicing such-and-such?"
Rather than having anything to do with studying Islam the religion, such questions are typically focussed on passing judgement (be that judgement right or wrong) on practices performed by particular groups of people, or in some cases judging particular groups of people directly. As a site which has struggled with sectarianism pretty much from the get-go, do these questions have any place here at all? If so, how can they be made constructive rather than judgmental?