Skip to main content
Islam

Return to Question

replaced http://islam.stackexchange.com/ with https://islam.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
Community Bot
Community Bot
  • 1

Consider my question http://islam.stackexchange.com/q/1243/44https://islam.stackexchange.com/q/1243/44 . It had some disagreement as not being a good fit for QA format. You can see the comments below it, and also the transcript of the discussion on chat here.

I think it is a good and on-topic because adab is part of the islam. A question like mine can be answered by saying "Prophet (s.a.v) advised this to its followers". On the other hand, manishearth says question is still have a make-a-list aspect. What do you think?

Consider my question http://islam.stackexchange.com/q/1243/44 . It had some disagreement as not being a good fit for QA format. You can see the comments below it, and also the transcript of the discussion on chat here.

I think it is a good and on-topic because adab is part of the islam. A question like mine can be answered by saying "Prophet (s.a.v) advised this to its followers". On the other hand, manishearth says question is still have a make-a-list aspect. What do you think?

Consider my question https://islam.stackexchange.com/q/1243/44 . It had some disagreement as not being a good fit for QA format. You can see the comments below it, and also the transcript of the discussion on chat here.

I think it is a good and on-topic because adab is part of the islam. A question like mine can be answered by saying "Prophet (s.a.v) advised this to its followers". On the other hand, manishearth says question is still have a make-a-list aspect. What do you think?

Source Link
user44
user44

Are adab questions too open ended, or listy?

Consider my question http://islam.stackexchange.com/q/1243/44 . It had some disagreement as not being a good fit for QA format. You can see the comments below it, and also the transcript of the discussion on chat here.

I think it is a good and on-topic because adab is part of the islam. A question like mine can be answered by saying "Prophet (s.a.v) advised this to its followers". On the other hand, manishearth says question is still have a make-a-list aspect. What do you think?